The Extreme Inefficiency of the Schumpeterian Solution to Scale Effects
- Working Paper
As populations have grown, growth has not accelerated. Many growth models attribute this lack of “scale effects” primarily to Schumpeterian forces that spread equilibrium research effort over an expanding range of goods. In these models, restricting variety would accelerate growth. Under standard assumptions, the welfare gain of permanently shrinking variety to early modern levels is equivalent to a ∼100x level effect. This conclusion is avoidable with severely diminishing returns to R&D, but this assumption is empirically questionable and almost rules out scale effects exogenously. This suggests that Schumpeterian product proliferation is not the primary solution to scale effects.